Another idea I have, also from my previous topic brainstorm, addresses the prompt that asks me to choose a female character to focus on and discuss several questions about her. For this project I think I would discuss the character Du Tenth from Feng Menglong's "Du Tenth Sinks the Jewel Box in Anger." For this project, I would address how several characters view her in a negative manner and share my contrasting opinion about her. I'm interested in this topic because I felt sympathetic for Du Tenth the whole time I was reading this story. At first I had doubts as to whether or not her love for Jia Li was sincere, but it ended up becoming clear to me that it was sincere even if Jia Li didn't realize until it was too late and he had already ruined things with her. I could also write about Kieu from "The Tale of Kieu" since her story has a lot to talk about. She's been in plenty of different situations and has met a lot of characters who respected her, even if she never viewed herself with the same level of respect. From this project, I might end up learning something about the way that we as people perceive others who don't meet society's standards of what makes someone a good person and whether or not our judgments are fair.
My third idea, which is isn't from a previous brainstorm, is to write about the following prompt: "Pick a subject: love, work, freedom, etc. Then choose two selections and discuss how that subject is discussed in those selections. Use literary devices to help frame your discussion." For this project, I would pick the subject "love" and analyze the love lives of Kieu and Du Tenth. Kieu has a lot of love in her life. No matter what happened to her, she always had someone that loved her. Kim loved her before she disappeared and even after she came back. When she was gone, Lord Tu loved her and took care of her, going so far as to get revenge on the people who hurt her. Her family was also greatly relieved to see that she was alive and they reassured Kieu that she shouldn't feel like she doesn't deserve their kindness. Du Tenth on the other hand, wasn't well-respected nor did anyone have a genuine love for her. Jia Li came into her life and the two fell in love. Then he proceeded to screw everything up and betray her feelings by doubting the integrity of their relationship and how well their marriage would work out. Overall, I feel like there is a lot of content I could fit into this project.
My third idea, which is isn't from a previous brainstorm, is to write about the following prompt: "Pick a subject: love, work, freedom, etc. Then choose two selections and discuss how that subject is discussed in those selections. Use literary devices to help frame your discussion." For this project, I would pick the subject "love" and analyze the love lives of Kieu and Du Tenth. Kieu has a lot of love in her life. No matter what happened to her, she always had someone that loved her. Kim loved her before she disappeared and even after she came back. When she was gone, Lord Tu loved her and took care of her, going so far as to get revenge on the people who hurt her. Her family was also greatly relieved to see that she was alive and they reassured Kieu that she shouldn't feel like she doesn't deserve their kindness. Du Tenth on the other hand, wasn't well-respected nor did anyone have a genuine love for her. Jia Li came into her life and the two fell in love. Then he proceeded to screw everything up and betray her feelings by doubting the integrity of their relationship and how well their marriage would work out. Overall, I feel like there is a lot of content I could fit into this project.
Hey Sabian, I think you have great ideas for all three topics and personally I think it would be interesting to see what you would do for the second and third topic that you have shortlisted in your "Topic Brainstorm". For the second topic which you are aiming to focus on "Tale of Keiu" is a good start because i think this literary text is perfect for this as different perspectives are illustrated Kieu. Also, the author Du also shares his perspetive as he sees her as a really talented and beautiful young woman who ends up loosing her freedom as she's compelled to suffer because of her fate. For the third topic, I think it would be interesting to analyze the love between kim and Kieu and you're right about the fact that despite everyhting Kieu went through, she was still loved by Kim and she still chose to love Kim as well. Basically both fulfilled their promise to each other despite how long it had been for them since they last saw each other.
ReplyDeleteHey Sabian,
ReplyDeleteThis topic brainstorm is done very well because you give us a lot of depth into each topic and it allows me to actually see the direction you would go with if you did an essay on each one but good thing we don't so which ever one you picked I'm sure lead to a great essay.